Who Stays, Who Goes? Breaking Down the Buffalo Bills’ Free Agents – The Film Room

As the Buffalo Bills enter another crucial offseason, the front office faces tough decisions on pending free agents. Some players will return, while others may not fit the team’s cap situation or long-term vision. In this Film Room Special, we analyze key unrestricted free agents, breaking down their impact, strengths, weaknesses, and future with the team.

🎙️ Prefer audio? You can listen to this breakdown on:

🔗 Apple Podcasts | Spotify | iHeartRadio | Amazon Music

📌 Prefer to watch? Check out the full breakdown below!

🔑 Key Takeaways & Film Breakdown

🏈 Here’s a quick rundown of what we covered in this episode:

Key Unrestricted Free Agents

WR Amari Cooper

🔹 Impact: Trade acquisition, veteran presence, WR1 potential.
🔹 2024 Stats in Buffalo: 40 targets, 26 receptions, 338 yards, 2 TDs
🔹 Film Focus:

• Supposed to be a true X receiver but didn’t consistently command WR1 attention.
• Big-play ability but struggled with route leverage, miscommunications with Josh Allen.
• Late-season decline in explosiveness.
• Decision: Is he worth re-signing, or could a draft pick fill his role?

WR Mack Hollins

🔹 Impact: Blocking WR, special teams ace, red-zone weapon.
🔹 2024 Red Zone Stats: 7 targets, 5 receptions, 4 TDs
🔹 Film Focus:

• Dirty Work: Elite blocker, key in run-game execution.
• Red Zone Efficiency: 1.17 EPA/target.
• Decision: Do the Bills need a cheaper, younger option?

CB Rasul Douglas

🔹 Impact: Strong off zone defender.
🔹 Film Focus:

• High-level zone coverage, great tackler, but turnovers declined compared to 2023.
• Press coverage concerns: Lacks burst at LOS, allows early separation.
• Decision: Will his contract demands fit within the team’s defensive balance?

RB Ty Johnson

🔹 Impact: Change-of-pace back, strong third-down presence.
🔹 Film Focus:

• Good blitz recognition, solid pass-blocking, scramble drill trust.
• Decision: Is his role necessary, or can Cook/Davis replace him?

DE Dawuane Smoot

🔹 Impact: Versatile pass-rusher, high motor.
🔹 Film Focus:

• Effective on third downs, stunts, and short-yardage stops.
• Decision: Does his leadership and rotational value warrant a new deal?

S Damar Hamlin

🔹 Impact: Depth safety, special teams contributor.
🔹 Film Focus:

• Tackling improvements in 2024, reliable in open field.
• Limited in coverage due to athleticism.
• Decision: Is there still room for him in a shifting Bills secondary?

Other Notable Free Agents

• FB Reggie Gilliam: Special teams and lead-blocking—does he fit the team’s blueprint?
• DT Jordan Phillips: Locker-room leader, but can Buffalo go younger at DT?
• DT Quinton Jefferson: Low-cost rotational piece or time to move on?
• LS Reid Ferguson: Reliable long snapper—should he return?

Final Thoughts & Predictions

🔹 Who are the Bills’ must re-sign players?
🔹 Which free agents are likely gone due to cap or scheme fit?
🔹 Are there any sleeper free agents who could surprise and return?
🔹 How will these decisions shape the Bills’ 2025 roster & draft strategy?

⏳ Jump to your favorite part of the breakdown:

Chapters

• 0:00 – Introduction + Opening Thoughts
• 3:14 – Show Format Change Discussion
• 7:11 – List of Bills Free Agents
• 7:54 – Amari Cooper Discussion and Stat Breakdown
• 14:02 – Thoughts on Re-Signing Cooper and Metrics
• 20:05 – Film Review: Josh Allen and Amari Cooper Incompletions and Completions
• 22:52 – Can Joe Brady feature Amari Cooper More if He is Re-Signed?
• 25:20 – Mack Hollins Discussion
• 26:23 – Film Review: Mack Hollins As a Blocker and Free Agent Discussion
• 32:33 – Ty Johnson Discussion + Stats Breakdown
• 40:43 – Rasul Douglas Discussion
• 43:18 – Film Review: Rasul Douglas Lapses in Coverage
• 45:30 – Do the Bills Re-Sign Douglas / Do They Look For More Athletic Corners?
• 47:06 – Bills Corners Man Coverage Stats Breakdown
• 51:35 – Damar Hamlin Discussion
• 55:23 – Does the Safety Room Need to Change?
• 59:30 – Dawuane Smoot Discussion
• 1:00:47 – Film Review: Dawuane Smoot’s Versatility
• 1:05:00 – Should the Bills Re-Sign Smoot?
• 1:07:22 – Quinton Jefferson, Jordan Phillips, Austin Johnson Discussion
• 1:09:20 – Superchat – Kenneth Grant Question
• 1:12:49 – Reggie Gilliam, Quintin Morris, Alec Anderson Discussion
• 1:16:29 – Preview of Next Week’s Breakdown + Final Thoughts

💬 Join the Discussion!

💭 Who do you think will come back to the Bills in free agency? Let us know in the comments below or join the discussion on social media!

📲 Follow us on:

• Twitter: @Cover1
• Discord: Join the Cover 1 Community